Mercedes-Benz GLA Forum banner

New Discs for GLA45

3480 Views 16 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  Whiterabbitt
Are the brakes the same for the 2015 GLA45 as the CLA45? I was looking at these genuine brakes:


And are the Brembo the same or better than the OEM?


Thanks!

Jim
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Can't add much value to this conversation, sorry Jimbo. I was under the impression that the brakes were Brembo's re-branded? Curious to the reality of this.
I just swapped out my front brakes two weeks ago.

I used Brembo discs. they were cheap enough. I don't think they were piece-perfect copies, so I don't think I can say the OEM is brembo, but I don't think it really matters. They are effectively brembo. My "OEM" pads were textar branded, which is strange because when I look online for factory pads it's always MB OE with textar as the replacement. I've been on textar since day 1.

Well, no more of that, anyway. I went with Hawk HPS 5.0.

I'm not a big believer in drilled or slotted, but I knew the brembos fit and the price was OK, so I went with it. I see vivd (I think it's vivd?) with light rotors on clearance, but at a 400% premium over brembo. I don't think I'd get $600 worth of benefit in pulling 10 pounds out of each wheel. Maybe you might?
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I just swapped out my front brakes two weeks ago.

I used Brembo discs. they were cheap enough. I don't think they were piece-perfect copies, so I don't think I can say the OEM is brembo, but I don't think it really matters. They are effectively brembo. My "OEM" pads were textar branded, which is strange because when I look online for factory pads it's always MB OE with textar as the replacement. I've been on textar since day 1.

Well, no more of that, anyway. I went with Hawk HPS 5.0.

I'm not a big believer in drilled or slotted, but I knew the brembos fit and the price was OK, so I went with it. I see vivd (I think it's vivd?) with light rotors on clearance, but at a 400% premium over brembo. I don't think I'd get $600 worth of benefit in pulling 10 pounds out of each wheel. Maybe you might?
So, how do you feel about the discs and pads now?
Third factor, flushed the fluid totally with Motul RBF 600. I couldn't get a straight answer from MB about the OEM fluid dry and wet boiling point, so it got swapped out. Took 3 liters since there is a baffle in the tank and we can't siphon old fluid out of the reservoir, just keep adding and bleeding.

Anyway, I need to talk to my colleagues at work who track often. Based on what they say and SpeedSF folks say (and they seem to agree), my takeaway is that brakes should have a healthy ramp through the pedal stroke, implying initial bite is "bad", and braking should be roughly linear.

That is about what I get with the HPS5.0 pads. There is very little brake bite, and certainly noticeably less than the OEMs (not the the OEMs have crazy bite, but they did bite a bit). Braking is predictable through the stroke, all the way to very heavy braking. At no time did my tires ever lose traction from braking (straight line or otherwise). At times there was very heavy braking because my instructor came down super-slow to hit turn 11, and we were getting pretty good at flying out of turn 10.

There was zero fade. absolute zero, and they performed consistent from the first 5 minutes of the first session all the way to the last 5 minutes of the last session. I cannot say the same about my tires which were greasy and crying for help by the middle of the 4th session. Braking consistency was an absolute highlight.

Where I want to consult those with more track time, is how much effort I needed to apply for braking. Since the initial bite is low and the progression is pretty linear, I end up sitting deeper in the brake lever more often to get the braking power I want. And sitting deeper in braking means I am putting more effort into pushing on the pedal. That means I am pushing very hard on the brakes coming into turn 11. Is the increased effort normal, no big deal, even desirable? I don't know. Before HPDE I assumed brakes should hit hard and be effortless, and have learned that is NOT the case at all. But I don't know if effort should be ramping up linear just like the braking force.

I also cannot comment on overall stopping power. As you know, we can stop our small cars in a hurry! Our brakes are already very good. I don't have the right tools to quantify stopping distance, and if TrackAddict can do it, I didn't have that resource with the OEM pads. My butt accelerometer tells me I have a bit more braking power now than with the OEM, but no data.

Overall, I am reflecting on them. Everything I am hearing and feeling tells me these are ideal brakes for my kind of driving (occasional track day). Combined with the Motul Fluid, it seems a recipe for total reliability and predictability for 2 hours of sessions on the track, which is about the peak of my ambition. It's hard for me to justify trying Pagid pads at twice the cost without confidence I will see twice the improvement. I think I'd be better off spending the difference on an extra HDPE day.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
For perspective, F1 cars require about 300 pounds of pedal force. I like large forces for full braking with a progressive pedal. This let's me control the amount of applied brake. But that's my preference. The key to your question is ... Are you happy? It sounds like you are. So you have a good set up. Especially since you're not seeing fade, even with the massive slowdown required to negotiate turn 11 (I am assuming we're talking Laguna Seca).
At the end of the day, yeah, I’m happy. I’ll pretty much stick with these pads unless I learn something revelatory.

That, and I didn't know if a set of pads was for one wheel or two, so I bought qty 2. So I have a whole set to do my brakes again in another 30-50000 miles. That's pretty much the life of the car for me.
Jim,

Regarding your kits you liked to, be careful about the CLA. The one you listed is for CLA with the sport brake kit. I have no idea if sport brake vs no sport brake option is meaningful, and when I was searching, I struggled to figure that out. I "think" the GLA and CLA are the same "without" the sport brake kit, but I'm not 100% sure. At the end of the day I went alacarte because the rotors are $100 less than the whole kit, the sensor is 12 bucks and then brake pads cost whatever for the ones you want.

I checked my ebay history. my brembo rotors are exactly the ones you linked to, from the same vendor, for the same price. They were the cheapest I could find.

For some reason the rear brakes are more expensive than the front. seems like MB should have just put the same discs as are on the front and saved some bucks.
I have the EBC Yellow. They require a large amount of pedal pressure, almost to the point they feel like faded brakes all the time.

This is my fear (Video), while hitting the brakes pretty hard, from 110mph, downhill trying to make turn 2, you will see how deep I went in the turn, it's because I was hitting the brakes hard before turning, maybe not hard enough. I actually think this is the fastest line here, it allows faster acceleration out of the turn.

Watch at about 6:15


Because at 8:14 you will see what happens when you are going too fast, I had to pitch it sideways and "drift" through the whole turn.
You are taking a much different line in turn 2 than my instructor did. The line as I understand it is to take the first apex wide, then hit the second apex and nail it, to set yourself up for the most exit speed before turn 3.

Now, we didn't carry much speed out of turn 1 because he was grossly underpowered, but we still had to brake into turn 2. Looks like we both were going into turn 2 at about the same speed range too.

2:35 is a closer match to the line we were using. your 6:15 lap, you turned way too early and came into the corner in the middle of the track already. 8:15 you didn't even go to the edge of the track, everything was from the middle inward. I know, I know, Monday morning quarterbacking, and your best laps are 8 seconds faster than my best laps... :)

After my instructor suggested most of the turns start at the white cone, my driving tightened up alot.


About 5:00 in was our line. This video only captures one instance of turn 2.

--------------------

The way you describe yellowstuff, I don't think I'm so eager to try them.
See less See more
I just saw this:


4:10 in, he's depicting what we were doing. Heck, even the thumbnail shows it.

I need to make time to watch this whole video, based on the 30 seconds I watched from 4:10 to 4:40, I wonder if the rest of the vid might not be super useful.
There are a number of different perspectives on turn 2, single or double apex, but both my 6:15 and 8:15 were not intentional, I was going deep because I was carrying too much speed and not braking effectively, however, the 6:15 going deep, may have actually been a faster lap time due to the quick exit from the turn. I looked up my sector times, and my Lap 3 which was my fastest at 1:52 had the fastest sector 1 time by almost 1 second, that is huge. That was the lap I went way deep into turn 2 at 6:15, just as I suspected. The turn, combined with the late braking may have given me a better time too.

I also noticed that this trip with the bad coil, I was crossing the finish line at around 95mph, whereas in Dec I was around 105mph. I can wait to drive it with everything working.
Well, looks like I'm going to order the Brembo discs and pads, the discs are due, and I don't like the heavy braking with the EBC yellow.
At the end of the day, yeah, I’m happy. I’ll pretty much stick with these pads unless I learn something revelatory.

That, and I didn't know if a set of pads was for one wheel or two, so I bought qty 2. So I have a whole set to do my brakes again in another 30-50000 miles. That's pretty much the life of the car for me.
What I am curious about is whether the Hawk pads eat the rotors as bad as the OEM pads do? I've only got 8500 miles on my car, with zero track days, and I've got almost 1mm of wear on the rotors. Pads show little to no wear (visually?). I'd rather change pads than rotors! That cast iron dust is nasty on everything.
Not sure, but check back in a year, ill measure for you.

dust and rotor wear are at the bottom of my concerns. Track stop power was at the top, followed by street power, followed by squeak noise. I always planned to do pads and discs at the same time.

but easy enough to measure for you, just need the mileage
Cool, thanks. My biggest concern also isn't the dust, and I fully intend on sticking with the Hawk pads on my vehicles. I just couldn't remember from my last car what that was like since it was a few years ago now. I think it was WAY better with the Hawks.

I'm just relating back to the racing days when we'd be swapping multiple sets of pads in one race, and never needed rotors. That was a Hawk pad/rotor combo on Porsche and BMW's in 24-hour races. I can't remember the exact pad though. I ran the same stuff on my street car and was very happy with it. I'd expect it to be similar with the new compounds they offer.
Update. My pads finally reached end of life after my last track day at Buttonwillow. I know BKM protocol for Euro cars especially benz is replace pads and rotors together. The OEM's completely eat the rotors.

The Hawk HPS 5.0 didn't. No grooves, no lip. So, I just swapped out the pads and fluid and went about my day.

I in fact bought HPS 5.0 for the rear and swapped them out (I've been running OEM in the back since day-1). My OEM pads are at 90% (swapped out last year) but the rotor is already 2mm lipped and has minor grooving. I'm trying the pads as-is on those rotors since "it's just the rear", though next go I'll definitely swap out the rotors. Only a couple weeks on it but so far so good. Feels much more positive than the OEM.

If the fronts on go #3 still don't eat the rotor then these pads are good candidates for fancy light weight 2 piece rotors.

-----------

That, or I'll play with carbotech XP10/XP8 pads next time. But it might be hard to pull the trigger on that knwing the pads are 3x the cost and that they will fir 100% certain eat the rotors.

----------

Anyway, interesting datapoint. 2 years of life out of the front pads with HPS 5.0 compound and light track use. Pristine rotors.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top